All articles
Lucas RappartCoaching· 3 min read

Design coaching vs mentoring vs a course: which one do you need?

Mentoring, coaching or a course answer different problems, and the wrong one wastes your time or your money. What each gives a freelance designer, and how to choose in two minutes.

Designers ask me this a lot, usually after a free session: "Should I book coaching, keep doing mentoring sessions, or wait for the course?" The honest answer is that the three formats solve different problems. Pick the wrong one and you either pay for what a free session would have done, or you collect advice for months without deciding anything.

Here is what each one gives you, and a two-minute way to choose.

The short answer

Mentoring is advice and perspective from someone further along, in short sessions, often free. It's great when you don't know yet what your question is.

Coaching is an hour on your case: your offer, your prices, your messages. You leave with decisions and a written plan. It's best when one question blocks you.

A course is the full method at your own pace: positioning, offer, pipeline, outreach, selling. It's best when you need the system, not one answer.

Mentoring to explore. Coaching to decide. A course to build the whole thing.

Side by side

Mentoring Coaching A course
What you get Opinions and experience Decisions on your case A method, lesson by lesson
Who leads You bring questions The coach, from your brief The curriculum
Depth on your situation Light Deep, one hour on it Up to you to apply
Time 20 to 30 minutes 60 minutes, plus a 5-minute brief Several weeks
Cost Often free $149 launch price, then $200 Shared at launch
You leave with Ideas to sort out A written plan and next actions A system to run every week
Best when You're exploring One question blocks you You want the whole thing

How to choose in two minutes

Three questions. Answer them honestly and the format picks itself.

  1. Can you name your question in one sentence? No: start with mentoring, or a free diagnosis. Yes: coaching.
  2. Is your problem the method, or your case? "I don't know how this works": a course. "I know, but it doesn't work for me": coaching.
  3. What do you need by next week? A decision: coaching. A direction: mentoring. A habit: a course.

Is a mentor the same as a coach?

Not quite. A mentor shares experience and perspective, often for free, and you decide what to do with it. A coach works on your specific situation until you have decisions and next actions. Many designers do both: mentoring to explore, coaching when one question blocks them.

Should you take a course before paying for coaching?

If you need the whole method, from positioning to selling, a course is cheaper per topic. If you're stuck on one thing right now, an hour of coaching gets you unstuck faster than ten lessons. Ask yourself whether your problem is "I don't know the system" or "I know, but my case is different".

How do you know if a coach is any good?

Three checks: do they still do the work they coach on, do they ask about your case before giving advice, and do you leave with something written. Reviews help, but the first two tell you more.

What I offer, in each format

I'm a freelance product designer, invoicing client work right now, and I do all three.

  • Mentoring, free: sessions on ADPList, and the free 15-minute diagnosis here: four questions, one call, one clear next step.
  • Coaching, one hour: $149 at the launch price. Your brief before, one hour on your case, a written plan after, and a check-in a week later. Everything is on the freelance design coaching page.
  • The Freelance Launchpad course: from positioning to selling, with a weekly 1:1 call. Price and date shared at launch, with the waitlist first.

Not sure which one? Start with the free diagnosis. Fifteen minutes to name what's really blocking you, and you'll know whether you need an hour, a mentor, or a method.

Get the next article by email

Pricing, positioning and finding clients, from my own client work. One email a week, nothing else.

One email a week. Unsubscribe in one click. Privacy policy.